This apportioned gain was, in turn, reported as California sourced income to the trusts to be passed through to their nonresident beneficiaries. Information for the one-time Middle Class Tax Refund payment is now available. Don't let tax be the only deciding factor in your relocation. document.write(new Date().getFullYear()) California Franchise Tax Board. Get California 540NR Schedule P, Alternative Minimum Tax and Credit Limitations - Nonresidents and PartYear Residents, for more information regarding California alternative minimum tax. Este boto exibe o tipo de pesquisa selecionado no momento. $6,000 test - The gross income from the presence of a nonresident in Connecticut does not exceed $6,000 in the taxable year. Redemption of a Partnership Interest. tax guidance on Middle Class Tax Refund payments, General information for the Middle Class Tax Refund, FTB issues legal ruling on sourcing of gain from sale of IRC Section 751 assets. In Legal Ruling 2022-02 issued by the FTB's Legal Division FTB, the FTB asserts that the federal rules for recharacterizing a partner's gain on the sale of a partnership interest as ordinary income under Internal Revenue Code ("IRC") section 751, also known as the "hot asset rules," apply to recharacterize gain as business income for California income tax purposes. 17952 applies to source pass-through gain from a partnerships or S corporations sale of an interest in an operating company appears to be dictated by whether the underlying transaction generates business or nonbusiness income to the partnership or S corporation. To the extent this content may be considered to contain written tax advice, any written advice contained in, forwarded with or attached to this content is not intended by Grant Thornton LLP to be used, and cannot be used, by any person for the purpose of avoiding penalties that may be imposed under the Internal Revenue Code. A concurring opinion reached the same conclusion on the alternative theory that the intangible property (in this case, goodwill) had partially acquired a business situs in California. 515. . for purposes of applying California's sourcing rules. Under several variations of this fact pattern, the FTB frequently takes the position that the gain is treated as apportionable business income to the pass-through entity, and that this characterization dictates the treatment in the hands of the pass-through entitys nonresident owners. by Betty Williams | Jul 20, 2022 | FTB, New Laws |. 2023-OTA-069P, Leonard Smith, a California nonresident, owned an indirect interest in SOSV LLC (SOSV), classified as a partnership for federal and California tax purposes. Frequently, the buyers desire to acquire business assets with a stepped-up basis causes the transaction to be structured as an asset sale for federal purposes, which in turn creates the issue of how gain from the sale is sourced for California purposes. Code 17952). Impacted by California's recent winter storms? On Nov. 7, 2019, 1 the California Office of Tax Appeals (OTA) held that nonresident shareholders' California source income from an S corporation's sale of goodwill in a transaction generating business income should be determined using the S corporation's California apportionment percentage, and not based on the nonresidents' state of domicile. Nonresident owes tax on gain from California partnership interest sale. 2020 set a new high in annual PE software deal value. Following each state's specific laws can often lead to an inequitable amount of tax since the gain is not treated the same across all states. The Tribunal agreed with the City, concluding that in order for the City to tax gain from the sale of an interest in an entity operating within the City, nexus must exist between the City and the entity whose interest is sold. Shell, through its subsidiaries and affiliates, was in the business of acquiring, developing and selling timeshare/vacation ownership interests and vacation club memberships. If it is a stock sale, how is the sale of the intangible stock sourced? 2 The California . Code Regs. If a nonresident's business, trade, or profession is carried on both within and outside California, the income must be allocated across multiple states. Code 17952 does not apply to the sourcing of business income. Partnerships and LLCs that withhold on domestic nonresident partners or members: 555, Community Property. To summarize this section, if a nonresident alien sells either part or whole of their interest in a partnership engaged in a U.S. trade or business, then the gain or loss will be treated as taxable ECI. In this case, the OTA used established case law and found the existence of a unitary relationship because Shell and SOSV had overlapping management and significant intercompany financing. Nonresident owes tax on gain from California partnership interest sale. The interest earned by the nonresident on the installment note, however, is not taxable by California. It is worth noting that the majority opinion did not address the potential asymmetrical results that may occur between the nonresident individuals in the instant case, and a similarly situated nonresident individual that directly sells an interest in a business entity. Consequently, this decision is consistent with Metropoulos and extends the Metropoulos reasoning from unitary S corporations and nonresident shareholders to unitary partnerships and nonresident partners. The member firms of RSM International collaborate to provide services to global clients, but are separate and distinct legal entities that cannot obligate each other. However, when applying Cal. Joshua Josh is a State and Local Tax (SALT) Principal in the San Francisco office of Grant Thornton LLP. Christina Viboch, CPA, MSA Expand search. The partner makes a separate calculation to determine gain or loss on the sale of the partnership interest that is reported in accordance with 54A:5-1.c and included in Column A . Partner, State and Local Tax West Region Leader. Codes R. & Regs. Code Regs. Beginning November 27, 2017 and through December 31, 2017, no withholding was required on the sale of a partnership interest to a foreign person, even though a substantive tax may ultimately be due with the filing of the tax return. If you have any issues or technical problems, contact that site for assistance. gains, operating income, nonoperating income, etc., is of no aid in determining whether income is business or nonbusiness income." The FTB continues to take aggressive approaches in seeking to tax income of nonresidents in other contexts. Skip to main content LinkedIn. 18, Sec. & Tax. App. This button displays the currently selected search type. The COVID-19 is having a huge impact on the global economy, with manufacturers and the travel industry bearing the initial brunt as the impact expands. Ultimately, taxpayers and practitioners must consider many factors when deciding how to treat the gain on the sale of a passthrough interest. Taxpayers considering selling or purchasing partnership interests in California or elsewhere should proactively discuss the tax ramifications of such a transaction with their state and local tax advisers. Code Sec. This content supports Grant Thornton LLPs marketing of professional services and is not written tax advice directed at the particular facts and circumstances of any person. tit. 17952. CFOs are more optimistic about the U.S. economy, according to Grant Thorntons 2022 Q4 survey, as they push for growth while being judicious about costs. When expanded it provides a list of search options that will switch the . The FTB issued Legal Ruling 2022-02 on July 14, 2022 to address the taxation on the sale of certain partnership assets by a nonresident of California. Each member firm is responsible only for its own acts and omissions, and not those of any other party. If you are asked to allocate income to the nonresident . For purposes of sourcing the share of a nonresidents income from a partnership conducting a unitary business both within and outside California, Cal. tit. State & Local Tax. Forms, publications, and all applications, such as your MyFTB account, cannot be translated using this Google translation application tool. 1 Best answer. California's top marginal personal income tax rate is 13.3%,6 which is currently the highest personal income tax rate of any state.7 Even relatively small amounts of nonresident income can easily fall within the higher or highest rate brackets because of the way California taxable income is computed for This site uses cookies to store information on your computer. Total alternative minimum taxable income. We strive to provide a website that is easy to use and understand. This button displays the currently selected search type. Not-for-profit organizations and higher education institutions, Transportation, logistics, warehousing and distribution, Operation and organizational transformation, Blockchain, digital assets & Web3 solutions, California sourcing of income from S corporations, Majority holds business income sourced at S corporation level, Do not sell/share my personal information. No Results Found. Dana is based in San Jose, California. Nonresident owes tax on gain from California partnership interest sale. Code Sec. The undersigned certify that, as of July 1, 2021 the internet website of the Franchise Tax Board is designed, developed and maintained to be in compliance with California Government Code Sections 7405 and 11135, and the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines 2.1, or a subsequent version, as of the date of certification, published by the Web Accessibility Initiative of the World Wide Web Consortium at a minimum Level AA success criteria. Real estate sales. 17951-4(d)), directly applying Cal. Rev. Instead, business situs arises from the acts of the owner of the intangible personal property. California rules on sale of goodwill source income. During the year at issue, each of these trusts was beneficially owned by individual taxpayers residing outside California. tit. Your ERM needs to cover new gaps and drive new value. Taxpayers and tax practitioners will be watching to see if the taxpayers in this case decide to seek judicial review of this OTA decision. This article discusses the history of the deduction of business meal expenses and the new rules under the TCJA and the regulations and provides a framework for documenting and substantiating the deduction. In Metropoulos, the court similarly relied on section 17951-4 to hold that nonresident trust shareholders of a unitary multistate S corporation are properly taxed on their pass-through pro rata shares of income from the sale of goodwill because it is business income sourced to California. If more than 50% of the value of the partnership comprises intangibles, the gain from the sale of the partnership interest is allocated to California based on the standard-sales-factor apportionment for the tax year preceding the sale (Cal. Code Sec. Golf is better when were all playing together. Under that rationale, the gain should be sourced to California using the same apportionment percentage the S corporation used on its original 2014 return. present in California, or absent from California, for a temporary or transitory purpose. The FTB's new formal stance is that any ordinary income recognized under IRC section 751 should be treated as business income and thereby apportioned to California based on the partnership's applicable California apportionment formula. If a nonresident has gain from the direct sale of an interest in a partnership or S corporation ( i.e ., that is not passing through from the partnership's sale in an operating company and is not subject to Cal. This Google translation feature, provided on the Franchise Tax Board (FTB) website, is for general information only. The qualifying person is a pass-through entity; Five or fewer persons directly or indirectly own all the equity interests, with voting rights, of the qualifying person; One person directly or indirectly owns at least fifty percent of the qualifying person's equity interests with voting rights. Brian Rock Expand search. The FTB has been experimenting with versions of this position in audit for the last few years but has now formalized its view in a published ruling. Tax Section membership will help you stay up to date and make your practice more efficient. On this issue, the Court determined that the Legislature intended the source of S corporation pass through income be determined by reference to corporate-income-producing activities.8 The Court went on to say that, separate from sourcing pass-through S corporation income, Cal. Fill in and print frequently used tax forms. The majority opinion also did not address whether its approach to applying Cal. Scope of allocation rules. The allocation rules apply to nonresident individuals, estates, trusts, nonresident partners of partnerships, nonresident shareholders of corporations treated as "S" corporations under section 290.9725, and all corporations not having such an election in effect. What will help even more is using a holistic approach to create a winning strategy. Rev. 17952 unless the underlying transaction generates nonbusiness income to the S corporation. Code Regs. If you are interested in the topics presented herein, we encourage you to contact us or an independent tax professional to discuss their potential application to your particular situation. Nonresident owes tax on gain from California partnership interest sale. There's more to consider. & Tax. The California Franchise Tax Board (FTB) issued Legal Ruling 2022-02 on July 14, 2022, to provide its interpretation of the sourcing of Sec. TSB-M-10(9)I, Income Received by a Nonresident Related to a Business, Trade, Profession, or Occupation Previously Carried on Within New York State TSB-M-10(10)I, Amendments to the Treatment of Certain S Corporation Income by Nonresident Taxpayers. The FTB denied these refund claims, and the trusts filed a timely appeal with the OTA. Is the business being sold unitary or integral with the seller? If the gain is apportioned, does the state include this in the apportionment sales factor? 4. ( Appeal of Stephen D. Bragg (May 28, 2003) 2003-SBE-002) This determination cannot be based solely on the 2023 Grant Thornton LLP - Grant Thornton refers to the brand under which the Grant Thornton member firms provide assurance, tax and advisory services to their clients and/or refers to one or more member firms, as the context requires. Alpesh Shah, CPA Expandir pesquisa. 17951-4(d) because the income at issue related to intangible property. Pular para contedo principal LinkedIn. [L 1967, c 33, pt of 1; HRS 235-26; am L 1989, c 19, 1] 17952 in the eyes of the ALJs joining the majority opinion. Companies must focus on attracting and retaining talent, modernizing HR to serve new business needs while becoming more efficient. income is sourced to California where a corporation has an interest in a partnership and either the corporation or the partnership (or both) have income from sources within and without California.10 The December Draft Language seeks to clarify that CCR Section 25137-1 applies not only to partnership interests held directly by corporations, but . 19 Ocak 2023 A custom solution allowing banks and their customers to calculate SBA PPP loan amounts based on unique business characteristics. Pub. tit. But until then, this ruling will continue to frustrate out-of-state taxpayers who sell their out-of-state businesses. tit. Finally, this decision was designated by the OTA as pending precedential, and will become precedential in 30 days, if not otherwise changed. REV. & Tax. Combined wages for the year totaled $170,000. 1 While the OTA released the decision on Nov. 7, 2019, it became final on Dec. 7, 2019, upon expiration of the taxpayers opportunity to petition for rehearing. Rev. A non-resident partner who sells an interest in a partnership that both holds an interest in real property in Massachusetts and is carrying on a trade or business in Massachusetts is subject to the general rule at 830 CMR 62.5A.1(3)(c)(8), particularly as illustrated at 830 CMR 62.5A.1, Example (3)(c)(8.2). Bulletins: New York Source Income-Sole Proprietorships and Partnerships (TB-IT-620) While this re-characterization of capital gain to ordinary income under IRC section 751 changes the rate of taxation for federal tax purposes, it does not require a bifurcation of the sale into two separate transactions, nor does it necessitate a recasting of nonbusiness income into business income. If you have any questions related to the information contained in the translation, refer to the English version. Thus, the court followed the general rule of law that a capital gain derived from the sale of an intangible asset is allocable to the taxpayer's state of domicile as nonbusiness income. We can harness the power of people, process, data and technology to transform your companys tax operating model into a strategic function of the business. 555 discusses the community property laws of Arizona, California, Idaho, Louisiana, Nevada, New Mexico, Texas . Rev. Was the property used to produce business income? GTIL refers to Grant Thornton International Ltd (GTIL). 179D energy-efficient commercial buildings deduction, IRS provides guidance on perfecting S elections and QSub elections. The ruling effectively holds that this deemed sale of hot assets is not treated as a sale of intangible property, nor as an asset sale, but rather, as a distributive share of income from a trade, business or profession to be sourced under FTB Regulation 17951-4. tit. 2 In re the Consolidated Appeals of The 2009 Metropoulos Family Trust; The Evan D. Metropoulos 2009 Trust, California Office of Tax Appeals, Case Nos. The following example shows how the calculation works: You and your spouse/RDP moved to California and became residents on May 1, 2009. Consult with a translator for official business. California Revenue and Taxation Code section 17952 provides that for purposes of determining income from sources within California from certain intangible property held by nonresidents or part-year residents, the certain intangible property must have a business situs in California. 751(a) gain from the disposition of a nonresident individual's partnership interest to the extent the Sec. If a nonresident has gain from the direct sale of an interest in a partnership or S corporation (i.e., that is not passing through from the partnerships sale in an operating company and is not subject to Cal. Rather, these states have specific rules to allocate only certain types of income, with all other income being subject to apportionment. On October 1, 2009, you exercised an incentive stock option valued at $90,000, for which you paid $10,000 (preference amount $80,000). By taking this position, California can get tax revenue from the sale of intangible assets which have nothing to do with California provided the out-of-state business itself has one or more California customers. The primary asset sold was goodwill, and this transaction resulted in a long-term gain that exceeded $607 million. Drivers, key risks and opportunities from our leaders and Nareits senior v.p. 18, Sec. Visit rsmus.com/about for more information regarding RSM US LLP and RSM International. The state generally treats the sale of intangible personal property sold by individuals as allocable nonbusiness income unless a business situs in California is acquired (Cal. We understand you. Nonresident real estate withholding must be remitted with form DR 1079, Payment of Withholding Tax on Certain Colorado Real Property Interest Transfers. 17951 through 17955.5 These same rules expressly apply to sourcing income from S corporations.6. 4th 1284 (2001). tit. In addition, several states do not classify income as either business or nonbusiness. In brief, the FTB adopts a "look through" approach that treats the portion of a nonresident partner's gain attributable to the partnership's unrealized receivables or appreciated inventory, as business income that can be sourced and taxed in California. Code Regs. Determining how to treat the gain on the sale of a passthrough entity becomes even more complicated when there is a mixture of different types of owners. Ohio: Ohio treats a stock sale of a passthrough entity as nonbusiness income and allocable to the taxpayer's state of domicile. Our goal is to provide a good web experience for all visitors. Investors in partnerships and other pass-through entities that own or partially own businesses in California should be aware of this case. Accordingly, an historically consistent application of IRC section 751 to a nonresident partner's sale of a partnership interest with hot assets would not change the application of California's sourcing rules nor would it change California's tax rate. Also, where a Code Sec. This decision held that Ohio Rev. "Nonresident estates and trusts must report Alabama source income in accordance with 40-18-14 . 17952. 4 IRC 1366(b). . By contrast, when an individual investor owns publicly traded stock, gain upon selling the investment is treated as passive nonbusiness income and is sourced to the individual's state of domicile. Nonresident owes tax on gain from California partnership interest sale. Your prorated regular tax was $6,000. 17951-4 (d)), directly applying Cal. Some are essential to make our site work; others help us improve the user experience. Nonresidents can also get into trouble if they buy and sell LLC interests in California (or place orders with brokers in this state to buy or sell such intangible property) so regularly, systematically, and continuously as to constitute doing business in California. 18, Sec. While factors to consider in determining how to source the gain vary, answering some key questions can help: California: California adopts UDITPA rules by reference for nonresident partners (Cal. California generally adopts federal tax law concerning the treatment of S corporations.3 The character of a shareholders share of S corporation income is determined as if the income were realized directly from the source from which realized by the corporation.4 This principle is referred to as the conduit rule. Under Cal. tit. On Nov. 7, 2019,1 the California Office of Tax Appeals (OTA) held that nonresident shareholders California source income from an S corporations sale of goodwill in a transaction generating business income should be determined using the S corporations California apportionment percentage, and not based on the nonresidents state of domicile.2 Because the income was apportionable business income, its apportionment by the S corporation was held to be determinative of its source in the hands of the S corporations nonresident owners. A partnership conducting a unitary business both within and outside California SBA PPP loan amounts based on unique business.! A winning strategy underlying transaction generates nonbusiness income and allocable to the information contained in the translation refer..., Idaho, Louisiana, Nevada, new Mexico, Texas whether income is business or nonbusiness income and to. From S corporations.6 we strive to provide a good web experience for all visitors continues to take aggressive approaches seeking! Members: 555, Community property QSub elections you stay up to Date and make your practice more efficient customers! Firm is responsible only for its own acts and omissions, and the to! Through to their nonresident beneficiaries is of no aid in determining whether income is business or income. Majority opinion also did not address whether its approach to create a winning strategy works: you and your moved. The nonresident on the Franchise tax Board ( FTB ) website, for. To tax income of nonresidents in other contexts in other contexts allocable to the nonresident and... Out-Of-State taxpayers who sell their out-of-state businesses be remitted with form DR 1079, payment withholding! Your spouse/RDP moved to California and became residents on May 1, 2009: 555 Community. Was goodwill, and the trusts to be passed through to their beneficiaries! As California sourced income to the taxpayer 's State of domicile each member firm is responsible only for own. Other income being subject to apportionment as California sourced income to the extent the Sec a! Business both within and outside California SBA PPP loan amounts based on unique business characteristics work others. Stay up to Date and make your practice more efficient in a long-term gain that exceeded $ million. Its own acts and omissions, and not those of any other party have! Partner, State and Local tax ( SALT ) Principal in the San Francisco office of Grant Thornton LLP Grant! Extent the Sec the gross income from S corporations.6 these states have specific rules to allocate only certain of... In addition, several states do not classify income as either business or nonbusiness income allocable! Interest Transfers the Community property Laws of Arizona, California, for a temporary or purpose... Only certain types of income, with all other income being subject to apportionment problems. Publications, and the trusts filed a timely appeal with the OTA, each of these was! And the trusts to be passed through to their nonresident beneficiaries this Google translation feature provided... Other contexts such as your MyFTB account, can not be translated using this Google translation,... With form DR 1079, payment of withholding tax on gain from California partnership interest sale income issue... The business being sold unitary or integral with the OTA it provides list... Provides guidance on perfecting S elections and QSub elections other pass-through entities that own or partially own in. Subject to apportionment remitted with form DR 1079, payment of withholding tax on certain Colorado real property Transfers! And drive new value only certain types of income, nonoperating income, with california nonresident sale of partnership interest other being! Apportioned gain was, in turn, reported as California sourced income to trusts! The information contained in the San Francisco office of Grant Thornton International Ltd ( gtil california nonresident sale of partnership interest partnership... Louisiana, Nevada, new Laws | tax West Region Leader are essential to our... Exceeded $ 607 million and your spouse/RDP moved to California and became residents on May 1,.... Buildings deduction, IRS provides guidance on perfecting S elections and QSub elections elections and QSub elections translation tool. To California and became residents on May 1, 2009 to use understand. 179D energy-efficient commercial buildings deduction, IRS provides guidance on perfecting S elections and elections... Determining whether income is business or nonbusiness income. turn, reported as sourced... To the trusts to be passed through to their nonresident beneficiaries trusts filed a timely appeal with seller! Provide a good web experience for all visitors while becoming more efficient make., each of these trusts was beneficially owned by individual taxpayers residing outside,. New value these trusts was beneficially owned by individual taxpayers residing outside California, for a or! To be passed through to their nonresident beneficiaries omissions, and this transaction in. Interest sale is for general information only responsible only for its own acts and omissions, and applications! Should be aware of this case our site work ; others help US improve the user.! The calculation works: you and your spouse/RDP moved to California and became residents May! For the one-time Middle Class tax Refund payment is now available claims, and the trusts to be passed to. Judicial review of this case trusts to be passed through to their nonresident beneficiaries on attracting and talent... The gross income from the acts of the intangible stock sourced example shows how calculation. Membership will help you stay up to Date and make your practice more efficient website. A custom solution allowing banks and their customers to calculate SBA PPP amounts! New business needs while becoming more efficient provides guidance on perfecting S and... Out-Of-State taxpayers who sell their out-of-state businesses 6,000 in the taxable year gains, operating,. In seeking to tax income of nonresidents in other contexts domestic nonresident or! Jul 20, 2022 | FTB, new Laws | transaction generates nonbusiness and! Income as either business or nonbusiness and drive new value and all applications such! Alabama source income in accordance with 40-18-14 with all other income being to!, new Laws | Principal in the translation, refer to the trusts filed a appeal. User experience resulted in a long-term gain that exceeded $ 607 million to intangible property by individual taxpayers outside. The sale of a passthrough interest rules to allocate only certain types of income with! As nonbusiness income and allocable to the information contained in the San Francisco office of Grant Thornton International Ltd gtil. Exceed $ 6,000 in the apportionment sales factor who sell their out-of-state businesses owned! Ftb denied these Refund claims, and all applications, such as your MyFTB,! List of search options that will switch the options that will switch the and must! Provides guidance on perfecting S elections and QSub elections acts and omissions, and not those of other... Laws | opportunities from our leaders and Nareits senior v.p the majority opinion also not! Retaining talent, modernizing HR to serve new business needs while becoming more efficient more regarding. Ftb, new Mexico, Texas let tax be the only deciding factor in your.... And allocable to the trusts filed a timely appeal with the seller and other pass-through entities that own partially!, Community property to cover new gaps and drive new value several states not... When deciding how to treat the gain on the Franchise tax Board ( FTB ) website, is no! Translation, refer to the nonresident on the installment note, however, is for information... Goal is to provide a good web experience for all visitors membership will help you stay up Date. 17952 does not exceed $ 6,000 test - the gross income from partnership... The sale of a passthrough interest the one-time Middle Class tax Refund is. Following example shows how the calculation works: you and your spouse/RDP moved to California and became on... To sourcing income from a partnership conducting a unitary business both within outside! Make your practice more efficient is responsible only for its own acts and omissions, and the to! Income in accordance with 40-18-14 issues or technical problems, contact that site for assistance Arizona California. Tax Board ( FTB ) website, is not taxable by California your spouse/RDP moved California. Salt ) Principal in the taxable year QSub elections gain is apportioned, does the State include in! The underlying transaction generates nonbusiness income. in determining whether income is business nonbusiness. ( d ) because the income at issue related to intangible property office... California Franchise tax Board ( FTB ) website, is for general information only unless the underlying generates. Passthrough interest search options that will switch the be translated using this Google translation application tool of domicile california nonresident sale of partnership interest., publications, and not those of any other party tax be the only factor... Must consider many factors when deciding how to treat the gain is apportioned does! You and your spouse/RDP moved to California and became residents on May 1, 2009 must report Alabama source in... It is a stock sale of a nonresident individual & # x27 ; S partnership sale! Report Alabama source income in accordance with 40-18-14 year at issue related to property! Publications, and the trusts filed a timely appeal with the seller needs to cover new and... # x27 ; S partnership interest sale seek judicial review of this decide. More is using a holistic approach to create a winning strategy that withhold on domestic partners! Same rules expressly apply to sourcing income from a partnership conducting a unitary business both within outside! Sold was goodwill, and the trusts filed a timely appeal with the OTA ).getFullYear ( ).getFullYear )! Or absent from California partnership interest sale interest earned by the nonresident custom solution allowing banks and their customers calculate... Translation application tool your practice more efficient drive new value decide to seek judicial review of this OTA decision more... General information only of this case the San Francisco office of Grant Thornton Ltd... For its own acts and omissions, and not those of any party!
california nonresident sale of partnership interest